The Art of Education
Twice-Exceptionality · STEM · Dyscalculia

What If “Bad at Math” Is Only Half the Story?

Dyscalculia, twice-exceptionality and undiscovered potential

A handwritten math notebook connected by glowing lines to natural patterns such as a honeycomb, sunflower, nautilus shell and spiral galaxy, with a European town in the background.

Someone can be a brilliant storyteller and struggle to spell.

We understand that.

But can someone struggle profoundly with numbers and still have a mind that is unusually good at abstraction, logic, patterns, systems or conceptual mathematical thinking?

The answer is surprisingly unclear.

And that matters, because bad at math is not merely a description. In education, it can become a direction. It can influence what someone studies, what teachers encourage, what opportunities become available and, eventually, what that person believes they are capable of.

So perhaps we need to ask more precise questions:

And there is another possibility worth considering.

What if some highly analytical or conceptually strong people effectively disqualify themselves from mathematics — and perhaps later from science and technology — because school has already taught them that they are “bad at math”?

They may not know that they have unusual strengths. Their teachers and parents may not know either.

Particularly in a twice-exceptional profile, high ability and a learning difficulty can obscure each other. The learner may simply experience something confusing: some things seem to come remarkably easily, while something that apparently should be easy seems almost impossible.

So they may avoid math. Drop it when they can. Choose another direction.

And perhaps nobody ever discovers what else might have been there.

Does dyslexia make someone bad at language?

Dyslexia gives us a useful comparison.

Someone with dyslexia might struggle to:

Different people can experience very different difficulties.

And yes, a person with some of these difficulties may well look bad at language in school.

But that tells us remarkably little about how they might use language elsewhere.

Someone can struggle with spelling and be an extraordinary speaker. A storyteller. A salesperson. A comedian. A negotiator. A poet. Someone with an exceptional vocabulary or an instinctive feel for how words affect other people.

A brilliant storyteller can struggle profoundly with the mechanics of getting a story onto the page.

Language is more than spelling.

Difficulty with one part of language does not tell us everything about someone's ability with language.

So should difficulty with one part of mathematics tell us everything about someone's ability with mathematics?

What does “bad at math” actually mean?

Dyscalculia is much less familiar than dyslexia.

Someone with dyscalculia will often simply be described — or describe themselves — as “bad at math.”

But what does that actually mean?

Dyscalculia can look very different from one person to another. Difficulties can include:

The core features concern numbers, arithmetic and numerical processing. Some of the other difficulties above are associated experiences rather than defining features of dyscalculia.2

Already, bad at math starts to look like a remarkably imprecise description.

Because mathematics is also more than calculation.

It can involve calculation and number sense, certainly. But also logic, abstraction, pattern recognition, spatial reasoning, conceptual understanding and the ability to recognize relationships between ideas.

So what if someone struggles profoundly with some of the first abilities while being unusually strong in some of the others?

What if someone who appears bad at math is also:

The question is whether the two can coexist.

Can this person be good at science, technology, engineering or mathematics (STEM)?3

And if they can coexist:

Would we ever find out?

Are we sure we know what mathematical talent looks like?

Perhaps the problem begins with the phrase mathematical ability itself.

Mathematics can draw on:

These abilities overlap. They cannot simply be separated into neat boxes, and being strong in one does not necessarily compensate for serious difficulty in another. But they are not identical either.

So can someone be extremely weak in one and exceptionally strong in another?

There will be contexts in which the answer is no. Some mathematical abilities are indispensable for particular tasks.

But which ones?

What exactly are we measuring when we decide that someone has — or does not have — mathematical talent?

We already know we don't measure everything

There is at least one good reason to take that question seriously.

Long-running research following highly able young people into adulthood found that spatial ability predicted later STEM outcomes beyond mathematical and verbal ability.

In one cohort followed for more than 30 years, mathematical and verbal ability together accounted for 10.8% of variation in later patents and scientific publications. Adding spatial ability accounted for another 7.6%.4

Larger longitudinal research has similarly found spatial ability independently associated with later STEM degrees and occupations.5

Yet spatial ability was historically underused in traditional talent identification.6

That does not mean mathematical and verbal measures were wrong.

It means they did not capture everything that mattered.

A good predictor is not necessarily a complete description of potential.

And that leaves an obvious question:

What aren't we measuring?

What if the strength and the weakness hide each other?

This is where twice-exceptionality — or 2e7 — becomes particularly important.

A twice-exceptional person combines high ability or giftedness with a disability or learning difference.

But that doesn't necessarily produce a person who obviously looks gifted and learning disabled.

Sometimes it produces someone who looks surprisingly ordinary.

The strength may compensate for the weakness enough to prevent the difficulty from becoming obvious. At the same time, the weakness may suppress performance enough to prevent the high ability from becoming obvious.

The strength may help to hide the weakness, while the weakness helps to hide the strength.8

A learner who reasons unusually well, makes unexpected connections or continually questions underlying principles may not have those abilities recognized as giftedness at all — particularly if their school performance in another area is weak.

They may simply seem inconsistent.

Capable but careless.

Bright but not achieving.

Good at some strange things, inexplicably poor at others.

Or simply average.

So what happens when the learning difficulty involves mathematics?

How would we know what we're missing?

This is where the evidence becomes much thinner.

Dyscalculia has historically received much less research attention than dyslexia.9 We know that it is heterogeneous: different people can show different patterns of difficulty involving calculation, arithmetic facts, numerical magnitude and symbolic number processing.10

What we cannot currently say is that people with dyscalculia generally have preserved — let alone exceptional — higher-order mathematical reasoning.

The limited direct research does not establish that. Some research with children has found broader mathematical reasoning difficulties.11

So we should not replace one stereotype with another:

Bad at calculation? Perhaps you're secretly a mathematical genius.

There is no evidence for that.

But there is another problem.

Advanced mathematical and abstract reasoning in dyscalculic adults appears to be remarkably under-researched. And giftedness combined specifically with dyscalculia has received much less attention than giftedness combined with dyslexia.12

Perhaps a profile combining profound numerical difficulty with exceptional abstract or conceptual reasoning is extremely rare.

Perhaps it isn't.

How would we know?

If someone struggles badly enough with basic mathematics, when do they ever get far enough into mathematics for us to discover what else they might be capable of?

When “bad at math” is only half the story

For me, this is not an entirely abstract question.

I have significant difficulty with numerical processing, calculation and spatial reasoning. At the same time, abstract, conceptual and analytical thinking are areas that come naturally to me — and conceptual mathematical ideas can interest me immensely.

That combination does not make me evidence for a theory about dyscalculia.

But it does make the question difficult for me to ignore.

Like many people who struggle with mathematics at school, I learned what I could not do.

What I was rarely given access to was mathematical thinking without calculation and notation first functioning as the prerequisite.

Much later, I encountered mathematical ideas through logic and concepts rather than calculation. Gödel's incompleteness theorem was one example. Explained through ideas and structure rather than equations, it made me want to understand it, argue with it and keep going.

That doesn't mean I would have been a mathematician.

Perhaps I wouldn't.

But I never got far enough to find out what kind of mathematical thinking I might have been good at.

And that is a very different statement from I was bad at math.

Are we sure we know what STEM talent looks like?

This becomes particularly consequential in STEM because mathematics is such an important gateway.13

And mathematics genuinely matters.

Engineering, physics, mathematics, computer science and many other STEM fields require mathematical knowledge and ability, although what they require — and how much — differs considerably.

The argument here is not that mathematical requirements should simply disappear in the name of inclusion.

There is, however, an important difference between saying:

this ability matters

and saying:

this ability tells us everything important about your potential.

A prerequisite can be legitimate and still be an imperfect instrument for identifying talent.

And STEM does not need only people who can calculate.

It needs people who can analyze problems, recognize patterns, challenge assumptions, develop models, understand systems, formulate questions, create technologies, design experiments and make connections that other people have missed.

Many of those activities require mathematics.

But does success in school mathematics always identify the people who might eventually be good at them?

And what happens to someone who is highly analytical or conceptually strong but has already concluded:

STEM? No. I'm bad at math.

They may never choose the subjects that would allow anyone to discover otherwise.

What does this mean for inclusion?

This question becomes especially relevant when institutions are trying to broaden participation in STEM.

Women and girls are one obvious example.

A great deal of attention is rightly given to encouragement, role models, confidence, belonging, stereotypes, recruitment and creating more inclusive STEM environments.

But all of those interventions happen somewhere along an educational pathway.

What about the people who changed direction earlier?

This is not an argument that dyscalculia explains women's underrepresentation in STEM. There is no evidence for that.

And if the mechanism proposed here exists, there is no reason to assume it would affect only women. Men may be affected too — potentially in different ways, given gendered expectations around mathematical ability.

The broader question is more interesting:

Could some people with potentially valuable STEM abilities have stopped considering themselves candidates because an early difficulty with mathematics came to define what they believed they could do?

If so, attracting them later may be difficult.

They may already have chosen different subjects.

They may already have built an identity around being not a math person.

They may never appear in the pool of people a STEM initiative is trying to attract.

That means inclusion may require more than asking how to persuade more people to enter through the existing gate.

It may also require asking:

Who never gets far enough to find out?

The question underneath this article is larger than dyscalculia.

And it is larger than STEM.

It is about potential — and what happens whenever a visible difficulty becomes a complete description of someone's ability.

Bad at spelling.

But perhaps brilliant with language.

Bad at math.

But perhaps highly analytical, conceptual or capable of seeing patterns and relationships that others miss.

Those things are not equivalent to mathematical talent. Nor do they guarantee STEM potential.

But neither should we assume that difficulty with one part of a domain tells us everything about someone's capacity within it.

We already know that talent identification has underused abilities that later proved relevant to STEM outcomes.

We know that twice-exceptional profiles can conceal both disability and giftedness.

We know that dyscalculia is heterogeneous.

And we know remarkably little about dyscalculia combined with giftedness or advanced conceptual mathematical reasoning.

The consequences may also extend far beyond school.

If lifelong learning is something we genuinely value, then what people believe they are capable of learning matters. Someone who leaves school having learned I am bad at math may not simply avoid the next mathematics course. They may stop exploring entire areas of knowledge that appear to belong behind that door.

And that makes this more than a question about assessment.

It is a question about lost potential.

Education inevitably creates prerequisites. Some are necessary. But we should at least be curious about what happens when difficulty with the prerequisite prevents us — and the learner — from ever discovering the ability that might lie beyond it.

So perhaps bad at math should sometimes be the beginning of a question rather than the end of one.

What if “bad at math” is only half the story?

And how many people never get far enough to discover the other half?

References

  1. 1. The dominant, best-replicated account of dyslexia centers on a phonological difficulty (trouble reliably linking letter shapes to speech sounds) rather than a purely visual one. However, peer-reviewed research finds that a substantial proportion of dyslexic children — roughly half, in some studies — do report visual symptoms while reading (blurring, movement, doubling), linked to differences in the visual system controlling eye fixation and letter-order tracking. See: International Dyslexia Association, Definition of Dyslexia; Stein, J. “Dyslexia: the Role of Vision and Visual Attention.” Current Developmental Disorders Reports, 2014, DOI: 10.1007/s40474-014-0030-6; Vellutino, F. R., letter-copying research summarized in University of Michigan Dyslexia Help, “Dyslexia Myths and Facts.” ↑
  2. 2. Research on dyscalculia centers on difficulties involving numbers, arithmetic and numerical processing, while individual profiles can vary considerably. Difficulties involving time, money or spatial orientation may also be reported alongside dyscalculia, but they are not present in every profile. See: Butterworth, B., Varma, S., & Laurillard, D. “Dyscalculia: From Brain to Education.” Science, 334(6057), 761, 2011, DOI: 10.1126/science.1201536; Träff, U., Olsson, L., Östergren, R., & Skagerlund, K. “Heterogeneity of Developmental Dyscalculia: Cases with Different Deficit Profiles.” Frontiers in Psychology, 7:2000, 2017, DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.02000. ↑
  3. 3. STEM: Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics — a broad group of fields and careers including the natural sciences, engineering, computing, technology and mathematics. ↑
  4. 4. Kell, H. J., Lubinski, D., Benbow, C. P., & Steiger, J. H. “Creativity and Technical Innovation: Spatial Ability’s Unique Role.” Psychological Science, 24(9), 1831–1836, 2013, DOI: 10.1177/0956797613478615. ↑
  5. 5. Wai, J., Lubinski, D., & Benbow, C. P. “Spatial Ability for STEM Domains.” Journal of Educational Psychology, 101(4), 817–835, 2009, DOI: 10.1037/a0016127. ↑
  6. 6. Webb, R. M., Lubinski, D., & Benbow, C. P. “Spatial ability: A neglected dimension in talent searches for intellectually precocious youth.” Journal of Educational Psychology, 99, 397–420, 2007; Lubinski, D. “Spatial ability and STEM: A sleeping giant for talent identification and development.” Personality and Individual Differences, 49(4), 344–351, 2010. ↑
  7. 7. Twice-exceptional (2e) describes people who are both gifted/high-ability and have a learning difficulty or neurodivergence, such as dyslexia, dyscalculia, ADHD, autism or dyspraxia. Giftedness does not simply mean being “good at school” or being a high achiever. The Columbus Group's (1991) influential definition describes giftedness as asynchronous development in which advanced cognitive abilities and heightened intensity combine to create an inner experience qualitatively different from the norm. The Dutch Delphi Model of Giftedness (Kooijman-van Thiel, 2008), developed through a Delphi study involving gifted adults and professionals, describes a gifted person through interacting characteristics including high intelligence, autonomy, curiosity and passion, sensitivity, intensity, complexity and quickness of thought. Both perspectives therefore describe giftedness as more than high achievement alone and help explain why an uneven 2e profile can be difficult to recognize, particularly when high ability coexists with a learning difficulty such as dyscalculia. ↑
  8. 8. Brody, L. E., & Mills, C. J. “Gifted Children with Learning Disabilities: A Review of the Issues.” Journal of Learning Disabilities, 30(3), 1997, DOI: 10.1177/002221949703000304. Masking and compensation are well documented in twice-exceptionality generally; evidence specific to giftedness combined with dyscalculia is much more limited. ↑
  9. 9. Butterworth, B., Varma, S., & Laurillard, D. “Dyscalculia: From Brain to Education.” Science, 334(6057), 761, 2011, DOI: 10.1126/science.1201536. ↑
  10. 10. Träff, U., Olsson, L., Östergren, R., & Skagerlund, K. “Heterogeneity of Developmental Dyscalculia: Cases with Different Deficit Profiles.” Frontiers in Psychology, 7:2000, 2017, DOI: 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.02000. ↑
  11. 11. Morsanyi, K., Devine, A., Nobes, A., & Szűcs, D. “The link between logic, mathematics and imagination: evidence from children with developmental dyscalculia and mathematically gifted children.” Developmental Science, 16(4), 542–553, 2013, DOI: 10.1111/desc.12048; Roulstone, R., Morsanyi, K., & Bahnmueller, J. “Performance on curriculum-based mathematics assessments in developmental dyscalculia.” Psychological Research, 88(8), 2444–2454, 2024, DOI: 10.1007/s00426-024-02015-x. Both studies concern children and do not establish preserved or exceptional advanced abstract mathematical reasoning in dyscalculic adults. ↑
  12. 12. The specific combination of giftedness with dyscalculia has received much less dedicated research attention than giftedness combined with dyslexia. It is therefore best described as an under-researched area rather than one in which current evidence points clearly either way. ↑
  13. 13. Douglas, H. E., & Attewell, P. “School Mathematics as Gatekeeper.” The Sociological Quarterly, 58(4), 648–669, 2017, DOI: 10.1080/00380253.2017.1354733; Duncan, G. J., et al. “School Readiness and Later Achievement.” Developmental Psychology, 43(6), 1428–1446, 2007. ↑
Dubbel Bijzonder · STEM · Dyscalculie

Wat als “slecht in wiskunde” maar een deel van het verhaal is?

Dyscalculie, dubbel bijzonder en onontdekt potentieel

A handwritten math notebook connected by glowing lines to natural patterns such as a honeycomb, sunflower, nautilus shell and spiral galaxy, with a European town in the background.

Samenvatting

Wat gebeurt er wanneer uitzonderlijk potentieel en grote moeite met wiskunde in hetzelfde brein samenkomen? Bij mensen die dubbel bijzonder (twice-exceptional, 2e) zijn,1 kan hoogbegaafdheid samengaan met leerproblemen zoals dyscalculie. Hierdoor kunnen zeer ongelijke profielen ontstaan, waarbij uitzonderlijke capaciteiten en grote moeilijkheden naast elkaar bestaan en elkaar soms onzichtbaar maken. Iemand kan bijvoorbeeld grote moeite hebben met bepaalde aspecten van getallen of rekenen, maar tegelijkertijd uitzonderlijk sterk zijn in abstract denken, logica, patronen, systemen of conceptueel denken.

Dit artikel stelt de vraag of de manieren waarop we doorgaans wiskundig talent - en potentieel voor een toekomstige studie in wetenschap, technologie, techniek en wiskunde (science, technology, engineering and mathematics, STEM) - herkennen, zulke capaciteiten wel zichtbaar maken. Of leren sommige mensen vooral dat ze “slecht zijn in wiskunde” en kiezen ze daardoor een ander onderwijspad, voordat iemand - inclusief zijzelf - ontdekt waartoe ze nog meer in staat zouden kunnen zijn?

Breder gezien stelt het artikel de vraag welk ander potentieel mogelijk onontdekt blijft wanneer een moeilijkheid op één gebied invloed heeft op hoe iemand leert, wat diegene kan laten zien en waartoe diegene zichzelf in staat acht.

[1] Dubbel bijzonder (twice-exceptional, 2e) verwijst naar mensen die zowel hoogbegaafd zijn / over uitzonderlijke cognitieve capaciteiten beschikken als een leermoeilijkheid of vorm van neurodivergentie hebben (bijvoorbeeld dyslexie, dyscalculie, ADHD of dyspraxie). Hoogbegaafdheid betekent niet simpelweg “goed zijn op school” of hoge prestaties leveren; het omvat een combinatie van extreem snel en/of complex denken, diepe nieuwsgierigheid, sterke autonomie, intensiteit en een sterke behoefte aan zingeving. Bij 2e-profielen kunnen de hoge capaciteiten en moeilijkheden elkaar maskeren, waardoor de hoogbegaafdheid onzichtbaar kan blijven voor de omgeving, maar ook voor de persoon zelf. Wanneer de hoogbegaafdheid niet wordt herkend, kan dit ook invloed hebben op hoe iemand zichzelf, zijn of haar capaciteiten en de ervaren moeilijkheden begrijpt.

Dvojí Výjimečnost · STEM · Dyskalkulie

Co když „špatný na matematiku“ neříká všechno?

Dyskalkulie, dvojí výjimečnost a neobjevený potenciál

A handwritten math notebook connected by glowing lines to natural patterns such as a honeycomb, sunflower, nautilus shell and spiral galaxy, with a European town in the background.

Shrnutí

Co když se v jednom člověku spojí výjimečný potenciál a výrazné obtíže s matematikou? U lidí s dvojí výjimečností (twice-exceptional, 2e)1 se vysoké nadání kombinuje s obtížemi v učení spojenými s neurodivergencí, například s dyskalkulií. Vzniká tak velmi „hrbolatý“ profil, ve kterém vedle sebe mohou existovat výjimečné schopnosti a výrazné obtíže - a navzájem se mohou zneviditelňovat. Člověk může mít například velké problémy s některými aspekty čísel nebo počítání, a přitom vykazovat mimořádné schopnosti v abstraktním myšlení, logice, rozpoznávání vzorců, systémech nebo konceptuálním myšlení.

Hlavní otázkou je, zda způsoby, kterými běžně rozpoznáváme matematické nadání - a potenciál pro budoucí studium v oblasti přírodních věd, technologií, techniky a matematiky (science, technology, engineering and mathematics, STEM) - skutečně umožňují takový potenciál rozpoznat. Nebo se někteří lidé především naučí, že jsou „špatní na matematiku“, a zvolí si jinou vzdělávací cestu dříve, než někdo - včetně jich samotných - zjistí, čeho dalšího by mohli být schopni?

V širším kontextu se otevírá ještě další otázka: jaký další potenciál může zůstat neobjevený, pokud obtíž v jedné oblasti ovlivňuje způsob, jakým se člověk učí, co dokáže ukázat a co sám považuje za své možnosti?

[1] Dvojí výjimečnost (twice-exceptional, 2e) označuje lidi, kteří mají vysoké nadání / výjimečné kognitivní schopnosti a zároveň obtíže v učení spojené s neurodivergencí (například dyslexií, dyskalkulií, ADHD nebo dyspraxií). Vysoké nadání neznamená jednoduše „být dobrý ve škole“ nebo dosahovat výborných výsledků; zahrnuje kombinaci mimořádně rychlého a/nebo komplexního myšlení, hluboké zvídavosti, silné autonomie, intenzity a silné potřeby smyslu v životě. U 2e profilů se mohou vysoké schopnosti a obtíže navzájem maskovat, takže nadání může zůstat skryté nejen před okolím, ale i před samotným člověkem. Pokud nadání zůstává nerozpoznané, může to ovlivnit také to, jak člověk chápe sám sebe, své schopnosti a obtíže, které zažívá.

Dvojitá Výnimočnosť · STEM · Dyskalkúlia

Čo ak „zlý v matematike“ nehovorí všetko?

Dyskalkúlia, dvojitá výnimočnosť a neobjavený potenciál

A handwritten math notebook connected by glowing lines to natural patterns such as a honeycomb, sunflower, nautilus shell and spiral galaxy, with a European town in the background.

Zhrnutie

Čo ak sa v jednom človeku spája výnimočný potenciál a výrazné ťažkosti s matematikou? U ľudí s dvojitou výnimočnosťou (twice-exceptional, 2e)1 sa vysoké nadanie spája s ťažkosťami v učení súvisiacimi s neurodivergenciou, napríklad s dyskalkúliou. Vzniká tak veľmi nerovnomerný profil, v ktorom môžu vedľa seba existovať výnimočné schopnosti a výrazné ťažkosti - a navzájom sa môžu zneviditelňovať. Človek môže mať napríklad veľké problémy s niektorými aspektmi čísel alebo počítania, a pritom prejavovať mimoriadne schopnosti v abstraktnom myslení, logike, rozpoznávaní vzorcov, systémoch alebo konceptuálnom myslení.

Hlavnou otázkou je, či spôsoby, ktorými bežne rozpoznávame matematické nadanie - a potenciál pre budúce štúdium v oblasti prírodných vied, technológií, techniky a matematiky (science, technology, engineering and mathematics, STEM) - skutočne umožňujú takýto potenciál rozpoznať. Alebo sa niektorí ľudia predovšetkým naučia, že sú „zlí v matematike“, a vyberú si inú vzdelávaciu cestu skôr, než niekto - vrátane ich samotných - zistí, čoho ďalšieho by mohli byť schopní?

V širšom kontexte sa otvára ešte ďalšia otázka: aký ďalší potenciál môže zostať neobjavený, ak ťažkosť v jednej oblasti ovplyvňuje spôsob, akým sa človek učí, čo dokáže ukázať a čo sám považuje za svoje možnosti?

[1] Dvojitá výnimočnosť (twice-exceptional, 2e) označuje ľudí, ktorí majú vysoké nadanie / výnimočné kognitívne schopnosti a zároveň ťažkosti v učení súvisiace s neurodivergenciou (napríklad dyslexiou, dyskalkúliou, ADHD alebo dyspraxiou). Vysoké nadanie neznamená jednoducho „byť dobrý v škole“ alebo dosahovať vynikajúce výsledky; zahŕňa kombináciu mimoriadne rýchleho a/alebo komplexného myslenia, hlbokej zvedavosti, silnej autonómie, intenzity a silnej potreby zmyslu v živote. Pri 2e profiloch sa môžu vysoké schopnosti a ťažkosti navzájom maskovať, takže nadanie môže zostať skryté nielen pred okolím, ale aj pred samotným človekom. Ak nadanie zostáva nerozpoznané, môže to ovplyvniť aj to, ako človek chápe sám seba, svoje schopnosti a ťažkosti, ktoré zažíva.